What are the difference of regular employees and Working Students in Germany?

From an employer's perspective, there are several key differences between a Werkstudent contract and a regular employment contract in Germany. These differences primarily revolve around costs, social security contributions, working hours, and the nature of the employment relationship. Here’s a breakdown of the main distinctions.

Feature	Werkstudent Contract	Regular Employment Contract
Social Security Contributions	Reduced (no health/unemployment insurance)	Full contributions (health, unemployment, etc.)
Working Hours	Max 20 hours/week during semester	No limit (as per full-time/part-time contract)
Employment Costs	Lower for the employer	Higher due to full contributions and benefits
Contract Duration	Temporary, linked to student status	Can be permanent or temporary
Taxation	Tax advantages for students	Standard taxation
Employee Benefits	Fewer benefits required	Full benefits (health insurance, pension, etc.)
Responsibilities	Usually entry-level or supportive tasks	Higher responsibilities and long-term roles
Flexibility	More flexible hours to accommodate studies	Less flexibility, often fixed working hours

1. Social Security Contributions

Werkstudent Contract:
- Employers benefit from reduced social security contributions for Werkstudenten. They do not have to pay contributions for unemployment insurance (Arbeitslosenversicherung) and health insurance (Krankenversicherung) as long as the student works no more than 20 hours per week during the semester.
- Employers only pay for pension insurance (Rentenversicherung) at the standard rate.
Regular Employment Contract:
- Employers must pay full social security contributions, including health insurance, unemployment insurance, pension insurance, and nursing care insurance (Pflegeversicherung). This makes regular employees more expensive in terms of non-wage labor costs.

2. Working Hours

Werkstudent Contract:
- A Werkstudent is restricted to working a maximum of 20 hours per week during the academic semester to maintain their student status and special tax/social security benefits. They can work full-time during semester breaks.
Regular Employment Contract:
- There are no such restrictions on working hours for regular employees. They can work full-time (typically 35–40 hours per week) or part-time, depending on the contract.

3. Employment Costs

Werkstudent Contract:
- The employer’s overall employment costs are lower due to reduced social security contributions and often lower wages, as Werkstudenten are generally students gaining practical experience and may accept lower pay.
Regular Employment Contract:
- Costs are typically higher because full social security contributions apply, and regular employees often expect higher wages than students.

4. Contract Duration and Flexibility

Werkstudent Contract:
- These contracts are usually temporary and tied to the student's enrollment status. The employment typically ends when the student graduates or can no longer be classified as a student.
- Employers often offer flexible working hours to accommodate the student's class schedule.
Regular Employment Contract:
- Regular contracts can be permanent (unbefristet) or temporary (befristet). There are no specific requirements linked to educational status, giving the employer more options for long-term employment.
- Regular employees may have fixed working hours, depending on whether the job is full-time or part-time.

5. Taxation

Werkstudent Contract:
- Werkstudenten benefit from certain tax advantages. If their income stays below the annual tax-free allowance (€10,908 for 2023), they may not pay income tax. This reduces the overall wage costs for the employer.
Regular Employment Contract:
- Regular employees are subject to standard income tax based on their earnings. There are no specific tax advantages based on student status.

6. Employee Benefits

Werkstudent Contract:
- Employers are not obligated to provide full employee benefits such as health insurance coverage, as Werkstudenten typically remain on student health insurance. This further reduces costs for the employer.
Regular Employment Contract:
- Employers must provide full employee benefits, including contributions to health insurance, pension, unemployment insurance, and other benefits such as vacation days and sick leave.

7. Job Responsibilities and Expectations

Werkstudent Contract:
- Werkstudenten are typically hired for entry-level tasks or roles that align with their studies. They are often involved in supporting or assisting positions, gaining practical experience in their field.
- Employers may expect less commitment in terms of availability and long-term career development.
Regular Employment Contract:
- Regular employees often have higher responsibilities and may be expected to take on more demanding roles with long-term development potential. There is often a greater expectation of stability and growth within the company.

8. Termination of Contract

Werkstudent Contract:
- These contracts are often fixed-term and tied to the student's academic schedule. The notice period might be shorter, and the contract may naturally end when the student is no longer eligible.
Regular Employment Contract:
- Regular contracts, especially permanent ones, usually have longer notice periods and more formal processes for termination. Employers may also face more restrictions on terminating permanent employees due to labor laws.

9. Vacation Entitlement

Werkstudent Contract:
- Werkstudenten are entitled to paid vacation, but this is usually prorated based on the number of days they work per week. The legal minimum for someone working 5 days a week would be 20 vacation days.
Regular Employment Contract:
- Regular employees are also entitled to vacation, often receiving more than the legal minimum (e.g., 24–30 days annually for full-time employees).

In this article...

Germany